Student of the Year: After Dark Review Roundup: 3.0/5 From 4 Critics, Worth It? (Dekhein Ya Nahi)

Student of the Year: After Dark reviews in one place: 3.0/5 average from 4 critics. Who can watch it with family, what is inside, where to watch (Dekhein Ya N

What the reviews add up to

Mixed reviews: good for fans

3.0/5

Average of 4 critic ratings · 1 positive · 2 mixed · 2 negative

Critics are split: some like the dark look and Shanaya Kapoor's double role, many say the story is confusing and does not make sense.

This is a plain average of published critic ratings, not our own rating.

📺WhereJioHotstar, since 13 Nov 2026 (6 episodes, about 35-45 min each as per Koimoi) · Hindi ✓
🔖CertificateNot confirmed yet

Should you watch it?

✅ You will enjoy it if

  • You like campus murder mysteries with lots of secrets and twists.
  • You want a short binge of 6 episodes with a young cast.
  • You are curious about Shanaya Kapoor's double role.

⏭️ Skip or wait if

  • You want a tight, logical thriller; many critics say the story does not add up.
  • You get bored by slow middle episodes and too many suspects.
  • You are not a fan of the Student of the Year brand and its young-cast style.

Who can you watch it with?

👨‍👩‍👧
With parentsMaybeDark murder story with teen drama; age rating not confirmed
🧒
With kids (under 12)Not idealMurder and dark themes like trauma and bullying, made for teens and adults
❤️
With partnerGoodA mystery you can guess along with, if you like the genre
🍿
With friendsGoodEasy to talk about who the killer is, even if the story is messy
🎧
AloneGoodShort 6-episode binge

Our estimate from the certificate and what reviews describe. Families differ; check the age rating in the app too.

What is inside the film

Fighting / bloodA little
Bad languageNot known
Romance / adult scenesNot known
Drinking / smoking / drugsNot known
Scary scenesA little

A student is found dead in a frozen lake and there is a deadly secret contest; reviews do not describe gore or sex scenes. Official age rating not confirmed, check the app.

What critics rated it

Each line is our own short summary in simple words. Tap the name to read the full review.

Koimoi Trishha Gaur4.5/5

Says the mystery keeps you guessing, the pace is quick and Shanaya Kapoor does well as twin sisters; only a few side characters feel thin.

Bollywood Hungama Bollywood Hungama News Network3/5

Likes the stylish look, the music and Shanaya's acting, but says the story goes back and forth, some things make no sense and the ending is confusing.

Pinkvilla Goutham S3/5

Enjoys the darker mood, fast pace and Shanaya's double role, but says it uses old teen-thriller tricks and the bond between the sisters feels weak.

Binged Binged Bureau1.5/5

Gave 3 out of 10 (shown here as 1.5 out of 5). Says the writing is weak, the mystery does not make sense and the acting is too loud; the look and songs are the good part.

Scroll.in Scroll StaffNo stars given

Says the show cannot decide what it wants to be, the acting is over the top and the twists go on so long you may want to skip to the last episode.

What viewers are saying

  • Many viewers on social media say it is slow and has too many twists and side stories.
  • Shanaya Kapoor's double role gets mixed reactions; some say she did fine, others are not convinced.
  • Some compare it to Squid Game and other teen thrillers and say it feels copied.
  • The music and the cold, snowy look get more praise than the story (as reported by TeluguOne).

Common themes from viewers online, in our own words. Opinions, not facts.

Songs and music

Critics say the songs and background music suit the dark mood (Bollywood Hungama, Binged).

Questions people ask

Is Student of the Year: After Dark worth watching?

Critics are split. Koimoi gave 4.5/5, Bollywood Hungama and Pinkvilla 3/5, Binged about 1.5/5. Try one or two episodes if you like teen murder mysteries.

Can I watch Student of the Year: After Dark with family?

It is a dark murder mystery for teens and adults. The official age rating is not confirmed, so check JioHotstar first. Better for older teens with parents than for young kids.

Where can I watch Student of the Year: After Dark in Hindi?

It is a Hindi series on JioHotstar, streaming since 13 November 2026, with 6 episodes.

Want to understand why some films work and others don’t? Try a free lesson at Script School.

Sources

We do not give our own rating. We collect what published critics and viewers say, with links, and explain it simply. Spotted a mistake? Tell us through our contact page. Last checked: 22 Nov 2026.

0 Votes: 0 Upvotes, 0 Downvotes (0 Points)

Leave a reply

Categories
Loading Next Post...
Follow
Search Trending
Popular Now
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...

       

T E L E G R A M T E L E G R A M