Sitaare Zameen Par Vs. Taare Zameen Par: Kaun Sa ‘Sitaara’ Zyada Chamka? (Mega Comparison!)

Namaste dosto! Aaj hum baat karenge do aisi filmon ki, jinmein ek cheez common hai – Aamir Khan aur dil ko chhu lene wali kahaaniyan! Ek taraf hai 2007 ki superhit “Taare Zameen Par” (TZP), aur doosri taraf hai abhi-abhi aayi “Sitaare Zameen Par” (SZP). Log bol rahe hain ki SZP, TZP ki agali kahaani hai, par kya yeh sach hai? Chalo, aaj sab saaf karte hain, kaun kahan chamka aur kahan thodi roshni kam reh gayi.

Pehle Jaante Hain Dono Filmon Ko (Kya Hain Yeh Filmen?)

• Taare Zameen Par (2007): Ek Asli Masterpiece!
  
  • Yeh film original thi, iski kahaani kisi aur film se copy nahi ki gayi thi.
  • Focus: Film mein ek bachhe Ishaan (Darsheel Safary) ki kahaani thi jise Dyslexia tha. Film ne bataya ki kaise ek bachha padhai mein peeche reh sakta hai, par uske andar kitna talent ho sakta hai.
  • Emotional Impact: TZP ne dil cheer diya tha. Log roye the, samaaj ne bahut kuch seekha tha. Iski emotional gehrai bahut zyada thi.
  • Aamir Ka Kirdar: Aamir Khan yahan Ishaan ke teacher bane the, jo ek ideal guide the. Unhone sach mein ek museebat mein fase bachhe ko sahi raasta dikhaya.
  • Visuals aur Music: Film ke visuals bahut real aur natural lagte the. Aur iske gaane toh aaj bhi dil ko chhu lete hain, ek dum yaadgaar.
    
• Sitaare Zameen Par (2025): Ek Nayi Shuruat!
  
  • Yeh film original nahi hai, yeh 2018 ki Spanish film “Champions” ka official remake hai.
  • Focus: Ismein intellectual disabilities (ID) wale bachhon ka ek group hai (jaise Down Syndrome aur autism). Film unhein basketball mein train karti hai aur batati hai ki kaise yeh log bhi zindagi mein bahut kuch kar sakte hain.
  • Emotional Impact: Yeh film heartwarming aur positive hai, aapko hasati hai aur achha feel karati hai. Par iska emotional impact TZP jitna gehra nahi lagta, thoda upar-upar se hai.
  • Aamir Ka Kirdar: Aamir yahan ek basketball coach bane hain. Unka kirdar thoda flawed hai, unki apni problems hain. Yahan Aamir perfect nahi hain, woh khud bhi kuch seekhte hain.
  • Comedy: Is film ki comedy bahut zabardast hai. Yeh aapko khoob hansaati hai.
  • Sports Element: Film mein basketball toh hai, par sports ka angle utna strong nahi hai. Matches ya training ko utna detail mein nahi dikhaya.

Kaun Kahan Zyada Chamka? (Sidhi Baat, No Bakwaas Comparison!)

• Originality Aur Kahaani:
  
  • TZP: Asli champion yahi hai! Ek dum naya concept lekar aaya tha, jisne poore desh ko hila diya.
  • SZP: Remake hai, toh originality mein peeche reh jaati hai. Kahaani achhi hai, par “naya kya hai” wala sawaal aata hai.
• Emotional Gehrai Aur Impact:
  
  • TZP: Emotional connection ek dum solid! Aapko rula dega, sochne par majboor kar dega. Iska asli “soul” yahi hai.
  • SZP: Hasi-mazaak zyada hai, dil ko khush karta hai. Lekin woh wali gehrai aur “heart-wrenching” feel nahi hai jo TZP mein thi. SZP ka “spirit” alag hai, light-hearted.
• Aamir Khan Ka Role:
  
  • TZP: Aamir yahan ek dum perfect mentor lagte hain, jinhone Ishaan ki zindagi badal di. Unki acting iconic thi.
  • SZP: Yahan Aamir thode flawed hain, galti karte hain, khud bhi seekhte hain. Yeh ek alag Aamir hain, jo perfectionist nahi hain. Kuch logon ko yeh pasand aayega, kuch ko lagega ki woh “extraordinary touch” missing hai.
• Subject Ka Focus:
  
  • TZP: Ek khas bachhe (Ishaan) aur Dyslexia par focus tha, uski apni struggle thi.
  • SZP: Yahan pure group (team) par focus hai, jo intellectual disabilities se jujh rahe hain. Message inclusivity ka hai, jo achha hai.
• Supporting Element (Art vs. Sports):
  
  • TZP: Art ko bahut khoobsurati se use kiya gaya tha, woh kahaani ka hissa lagta tha.
  • SZP: Sports (basketball) bas ek “prop” jaisa lagta hai, utni gehrai nahi hai. Sports lovers ko thoda disappointing lag sakta hai.
• Visuals Aur Pacing:
  
  • TZP: Visuals bahut real aur grounded the, lagta tha jaise asli zindagi dekh rahe hain. Pacing bhi tight thi.
  • SZP: Visuals zyada polished aur bright hain, jo kuch logon ko artificial lag sakte hain. Film kahin-kahin thodi slow bhi lag sakti hai, khaaskar second half mein.

Antim Faisla (Toh Kaun Jeeta?)

Dekho, “Taare Zameen Par” ek masterpiece thi, usne Indian cinema mein ek naya raasta banaya tha. Uska emotional impact aur originality koi match nahi kar sakta.

“Sitaare Zameen Par” ek achhi film hai, jo aapko hasaegi, positive feel degi, aur ek achha message bhi degi. Lekin, agar aap use “Taare Zameen Par” se compare karoge, toh gehrai aur woh “soul” kahin na kahin miss ho jaayegi. Yeh TZP ki spiritual sequel zaroor hai, par uska badla hua, halka-phulka version hai.

Agar aapne TZP nahi dekhi, toh SZP aapko bahut achhi lagegi. Aur agar aap TZP ke fan hain, toh SZP ko ek alag film samajh kar dekhiye, iski apni ek alag chamak hai! Dono filmon ka maqsad achha hai, bas kehne ka tareeka alag hai.

Aur agar aap review ko end tak padh hi rahe hain, toh please mujhe telegram par bhi join karein.

https://t.me/allthatisreviews

Wahan bhi main filmon ki baatein post karta rehta hoon. Aapka support bahut maayne rakhta hai!

Chalo, ab next review mein milte hain! Tab tak ke liye aap decide karo dekhne jaana hai ya nahin Sitaare Zameen Par.