Doston, agar credits ko dekha jaye toh clear hai ki Sikandar ko A.R. Murugadoss ne direct kiya hai.
Lekin jab aap puri film dekhte ho, toh kahin se bhi aisa mehsoos nahi hota ki ye unki direction hai. Aisa lagta hai jaise kisi ne ek idea de diya, background score chipka diya, aur bas jo mann kiya wo likh diya, shoot kar diya.
Film 2 ghante 16 minute ki hai, lekin kahin bhi proper build-up, drama, ya emotional connect nazar nahi aata. Aisa lagta hai ki film ko sirf jaldi khatam karne ke liye race laga di gayi hai.
Film ke pehle 15-20 minutes hi bata dete hain ki yahaan ek proper story telling ki kami hai. Scene kuch iss tarah hai:
➡ Action, gana, action, gana – ek continuous loop jisme koi emotional ya dramatic depth nahi hai.
➡ Characters ko develop karne ka koi effort nahi dikhai deta.
Agar ek film mein solid drama aur emotions na ho, toh chahe wo kitni bhi chhoti ya badi ho, boring lagne lagti hai.
Sikandar ka yahi problem hai – koi proper engagement nahi hai.
Rashmika Mandanna ka character ek crucial emotional layer add kar sakta tha, lekin writing aur execution itna weak hai ki wo kahin bhi connect nahi karti.
➡ Dialogues dull hain, performance bhi flat lagti hai.
➡ Salman aur Rashmika ke beech ka emotional angle bhi impact nahi create kar pata.
➡ Itna bada core idea hone ke bawajood, film uska potential waste kar deti hai.
Trailer dekhne ke baad lag raha tha ki film mein kuch dhamakedaar villains honge. Lekin real film mein:
➡ Teen villains hain, lekin teeno sirf joker lagte hain.
➡ Koi bhi Salman Khan ke character ke liye serious challenge nahi banta.
➡ Aisa lagta hai ki ek strong villain ya twist ki zarurat thi, jo missing hai.
Jab ek action film banayi jati hai, toh ek cheez toh zaroor honi chahiye – proper build-up. Lekin Sikandar mein:
➡ Action scenes bas randomly dal diye gaye hain, bina kisi emotional impact ke. Salaar movie jaisa nahin bana sakte the toh atleast uska 10% bhi action ko emotions ke saath connect kar dete toh poori movie paisa vasool ho jaati.
➡ Background music aur action scenes ke beech koi sync nahi hai.
➡ Ek bhi fight scene aisa nahi lagta jo yaad reh jaye. Fight scene yad tab rehta hai jab vo kisi emotions ke saath connect ho like Salaar movie. Aisi bohot si movies, I am taking just one example.
Haan, opening scene mein Salman Khan ka swag dikhai deta hai, jo ek momentary excitement deta hai, lekin uske baad film pura flat ho jata hai.
Film ka climax expected hai, koi bada twist nahi hai.
Haan, ek hospital scene hai jisme Salman Khan aur ek bacche ke beech ek chhota emotional moment hai, lekin wo bhi ek basic level ka hai.
Agar storytelling aur narrative strong hota, toh ye film engage karti. Lekin:
➡ Storytelling itni flat hai ki interval tak interest khatam ho jata hai.
➡ Drama aur emotions build karne ki koi koshish hi nahi ki gayi.
Agar hum Darbar ya Sarkar se compare karein, toh ye unse bhi weak film hai.
➡ Screenplay unorganised hai.
➡ Emotional depth missing hai.
➡ Action aur drama dono ka proper balance nahi hai.
A.R. Murugadoss jaisa director aisi film kaise bana sakta hai? Ye sochna hi mushkil hai.
Agar aap Salman Khan ke die-hard fan ho, toh shayad ek baar dekh sakte ho. Lekin agar aap ek solid action-drama expect kar rahe ho, toh disappointment ke liye ready raho.
💥 Positives:
✅ Opening scene me Salman Khan ka swag
✅ Kuch action choreography achi hai
💢 Negatives:
❌ Weak storytelling aur screenplay
❌ Poor emotional connection
❌ Villains impactful nahi hai
❌ Random pacing jo interest khatam kar deti hai
Agar aapne Sikandar dekhi hai, toh aapko ye film kaisi lagi? Kya aap agree karte hain ki ye A.R. Murugadoss ki sabse kamzor film hai? Apna opinion comments me zaroor share karein!