Rajkumar Hirani & Abhijat Joshi: 10 Writing Lessons From 3 Idiots and PK Writers (Script Kaise Likhein)

10 screenwriting lessons from Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi, from Game Changers Writer Series and their IFFI masterclass, explained simply with an exercise.

Quick answer: Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi, who wrote 3 Idiots, PK and the Munna Bhai films together, keep coming back to a few simple ideas: a story starts when a character wants something; the other side of the argument must be as strong as the hero; the audience must never think “this can’t happen”; and a film is really made on two tables, writing and editing. Below are 10 lessons from their talks, explained simply, with a 10-minute exercise.

WhoRajkumar Hirani (director, co-writer) and Abhijat Joshi (co-writer)
FromGame Changers with Komal Nahta, Writer Series, Ep 1 (YouTube) · IFFI 2025 masterclass “Film is Made on Two Tables” · MAMI 2015 session
Last checked22 Nov 2026

Their talks are mostly in Hindi. Lines in quote marks below are short translations; everything else is our summary in simple words. Watch the full episode at the end of this page.

1. A story begins when a character wants something

At their IFFI 2025 masterclass in Goa, they said a film truly starts only when a character strongly wants something. Want creates action, and action creates conflict. Joshi called conflict “oxygen” for a story (Indian Television, Bollywood Hungama).

Simple test: can you finish this line for your hero? “She wants ____, but ____ stands in the way.” If not, you have a situation, not a story. (We practise this in Script School Lesson 3.)

2. The other side must be as strong as the hero

Joshi said the best conflicts are not good versus evil but two truths clashing. The opposing argument should be as strong as the hero’s, because every character believes they are right (Indian Television, Navhind Times). In our reading, Virus in 3 Idiots works this way: he is not a cartoon villain; he truly believes pressure makes winners.

3. Never let the audience think “this can’t happen”

On Game Changers, Hirani said logic matters hugely, because the moment viewers feel something is impossible, the film stops working. But you can take small liberties if nobody notices. His own example: in 3 Idiots, several big events in the present-day story land on the same day, and viewers who have watched it many times rarely spot it.

The rule: coincidences are fine if they move the story forward fast and the emotion carries the viewer. They hurt when they solve the hero’s problem for him.

4. Biopics are a contract with the audience

For films about real people, Hirani said very few liberties should be taken. There is an unspoken promise: not everything on screen happened exactly, but most of it did. Breaking that promise breaks trust. (Related: our Real Story section checks what is real in films “based on true events”.)

5. Ask hard questions with innocence, not arrogance

Asked about PK, they explained why the hero is an alien: he has no idea about any belief on our planet, so he asks every question with the innocence of a child. Joshi said things that need questioning should be questioned, but with humility and without looking down on people’s faith. That is a writing tool: the right point of view character lets you explore a sensitive subject without sneering.

6. One word can turn a line into a classic

Joshi told a story about meeting Gulzar. He told him that one small, rough word in a famous Anand dialogue is what saved the line from sounding like a preachy quote and made it sound like a real person speaking. Gulzar asked him to sit down, and they talked for three hours.

Lesson: wise lines sound fake when they are too polished. Give them the speaker’s own voice: a slang word, a pause, a joke.

7. Expose information only after tension

At IFFI they explained that information lands better when tension comes first. A scene in 3 Idiots where important facts come through a phone call was moved to a more tense setting during writing (Indian Television). Viewers absorb facts when they are worried about a character.

8. A film is made on two tables

Their IFFI masterclass title says it all: “Film is Made on Two Tables: Writing and Editing.” Hirani said writing is emotion imagined and editing is emotion experienced, and that an editor “can flip a story 180 degrees” by changing the context of one shot (Bollywood Hungama, Navhind Times). He also said that on set, if you get 80% of what you imagined in a written scene, you should be happy, and that a big part of direction is managing people: actors and camera crew may each see the scene differently (Game Changers).

9. Where you put the camera changes the meaning

Hirani’s example on Game Changers: a crane shot that swings around may look grand, but sometimes the moment only needs a close-up of a face, because what matters is the feeling. (See camera terms in our Breakdown series.)

10. How to start: write, then make it yourself

Answering viewers’ questions, they said talent helps, but you learn by reading, film courses (they named FTII, Whistling Woods and courses online) and above all by writing. Hirani said the first thing he asks a new assistant is whether they have made a short film: today a phone can shoot, edit and publish to YouTube. Good scripts get found. They also said they happily throw away drafts, even months of work, when a scene is not good enough, and they take good criticism seriously.

Your turn (10 minutes)

  • Write your story’s want in one line: “____ wants ____, but ____.”
  • Give your villain the best possible argument, in two lines. Would a fair person agree with them a little?
  • Take one “wise” line from your script and rewrite it with one word your character would really use.
  • Find one coincidence in your story. Does it help the hero or just move the story faster? If it helps the hero, fix it.

Watch the full conversation

Game Changers with Komal Nahta, Writer Series, Episode 1 Part 2: Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi (official YouTube video).

Questions people ask

Who writes Rajkumar Hirani’s films?
Abhijat Joshi has co-written his biggest films with him, including Lage Raho Munna Bhai, 3 Idiots and PK.

What is Game Changers with Komal Nahta?
A YouTube interview series by trade analyst Komal Nahta. It has run a Director Series and a Producer Series, and now a Writer Series.

What did Rajkumar Hirani say about PK’s controversy?
He and Joshi said the Lord Shiva scene shows an actor dressed for a stage play, whom the naive alien mistakes for God, and that the film was written with good intentions.

How do I learn screenwriting in India?
Their advice: read, take a course if you can (FTII, Whistling Woods, online courses), and most of all write and make a short film on your phone. Start free with our Script School.

Sources

Spotted a mistake? Tell us through our contact page.

0 Votes: 0 Upvotes, 0 Downvotes (0 Points)

Leave a reply

Categories
Loading Next Post...
Follow
Search Trending
Popular Now
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...

       

T E L E G R A M T E L E G R A M